Meeting Members’ Wishes in the Last Year of Life: A Journey Toward Concordance in Southern California



 

David Glass; PhD Michael Kanter, MD; Paul Minardi, MD; Susan Wang, MD

https://doi.org/10.7812/TPP/19-039-29

Abstracts from the Kaiser Permanente 2019 National Quality Conference

From Southern California

Background: There is a large body of literature that posits that much of the medical care delivered during the last year of life is unneeded and unwanted. However, there is little evidence about how members view the amount of care, the types of care received, and whether that care matches their wishes. This study fills that gap. It provides insight into where Southern California does well and not so well from the member perspective, and why that occurs.
Methods: The results are based on 2 samples. The first was a survey with next of kin of 715 Southern California members (age 65 years or older) who died in April and May of 2017. The second involved administering the same survey to next of kin of 332 deceased members who died between June 2016 and May 2017 and whose costs during the last year of their life were in the top 10% of the costs of all members who died during this period. We examined the wishes, values, and health care experiences of the random sample of deceased members, then compared them with high-cost deceased members.
Results: The Southern California Permanente Medical Group (SCPMG), by and large, delivers care and treatments that strongly match the values and desires of its members at the end of their life. SCPMG does quite well on meeting members’ wishes overall, the amount of treatment, the specific types of treatments, avoiding delivery of unwanted treatments, and providing desired treatments. However, 3 areas stand out in which SCPMG might improve its performance: A) enabling those desiring to die at home to do so; B) avoiding cardiopulmonary resuscitation, mechanical respiration, or artificial feeding for those not wanting it; and C) managing the levels of pain. Surprisingly, those who received the most care (in the top 10% of costs) were less satisfied with almost all aspects of their care and treatments.
Discussion: A key quality metric is the degree to which members’ wishes and values are honored. It is reassuring that during the fraught period of the last year of life, SCPMG performs reasonably well and for the first time we have a comprehensive overview of our performance. There are several surprises underneath this broad finding, including 1) most members had engaged in end-of-life discussions with next of kin and physicians, contrary to claims that patients avoid these discussions; 2) most members said the amount of care was “just right,” again contrary to much of the literature; and 3) 38% of those receiving cardiopulmonary resuscitation did not want it.

Abstracts from the Kaiser Permanente 2019 National Quality Conference


 

Promising Methods for Improving Quality Through the Faster Spread of Best Practices

Abstracts2019TableThese abstracts reflect the critical importance of a forum for presenting promising quality efforts. Meetings focused on quality improvement, such as those hosted by the Institute for Healthcare Improvement, the American Medical Group Association, and many other organizations, represent a relatively small percentage of all scientific medical meetings. The publication of abstracts from a dedicated quality event such as the Kaiser Permanente National Quality Conference allows those inside and outside of Kaiser Permanente to learn about new and potentially unfamiliar practices that could improve care.

BEHAVIORAL HEALTH

The Impact of an Innovative Patient-Practitioner Therapeutic Community on the Management of Chronic Pain
Karen Peters, PhD; Barbara Gawehn, RN, LAc

Zero Suicide Implementation
Jacqueline Ryan, MPH; Pavan Somusetty, MD; Han Liang, MD; Eli Pahl, LCSW, CADC III;

Implementation and Dissemination of Cognitive Behavioral Therapy for Depression in Kaiser Permanente Hawaii: Impact and Lessons Learned
Bradley E Karlin, PhD, ABPP; Gregory K Brown, PhD; Shari Jager-Hyman, PhD; Kelly L Green, PhD; Michi Wong, PhD; Diane S Lee, LCSW, CSAC; Andrew Bertagnolli, PhD; Thekla Brumder Ross, PsyD

Lessons from Implementation of Behavioral Health Integration in Kaiser Permanente Washington
Rebecca Parrish, MSW; Ryan M Caldeiro, MD; Amy Lee, MPH

WELL BEING

100,000 Quitters and Counting—Striving for a Tobacco-Free Generation
Renee Fogelberg, MD; Mariko Muzzio, MPH; Annida Brunato; Karin Dove, MPH; Debora Sawyer, MD; Christopher Lee, MHSA

The POWER Journey of a Mid-Atlantic Permanente Medical Group Physician (Pursuit of Wellness, Engagement, and Resilience through Social Support)
Susan Leggett-Johnson, MD, MBA; Gene Gincherman, MD; Mary Zmuda, MPH

Malama Ola—Taking Care of Your Well-Being
Sharin Sakurai Burton, MD, PhD; Casey Akana, RN; Sandra Tompkins, RN; Kristy Yoshikawa; Julia Gregory, RN; Hyewon Jun, MD; Mae Lynne Swoboda, MPH; Courtney Farris, MA, MINTee; John Banagan, MPH, CHES; Eric Kamimura, DPT; Steve Nakata, COTA, MBA; Derek Chee, DPT; Quyen Nguyen, PhD; Jennifer Davis, RD; Kimberly Oshita, RD; Merle Miura-Akamine, MD; Kaipo Pau, MD; John Sheehan, MD

Increasing Team Safety and Response to the Threatening Member
Bradley Christie, PhD; Laura Ketterman, HEM

CARE MANAGEMENT

Continuing Care Quality Management: Practice, Performance, Proof
Peter Khang, MD, MPH, FAAFP; Jennifer Cortez; Christine Jordan, LCSW; Artem Aghourian, MBA

The Hepatitis C Care Cascade: Increasing Comprehensive Screening and Diagnosis
M Cabell Jonas, PhD; Michael Horberg, MD; Jacquelyn Redd, MD; Dana Sloane, MD; Eric Wollins, MD; Carla Rodriguez, PhD; Bernadette Loftus, MD

Measuring Diagnostic Error: A Review of Patient Complaints
Michael H Kanter, MD; Lawrence D Lurvey, MD; Kerry C Litman, MD; Ronald K Loo, MD; William Strull, MD; Mimi Hugh, MPH, MA; Maverick Au

No Place Like Home: Surgical Home Recovery
Michele Knox, MD; Wendy Rabinov, MD; Michael Nwynn, MD; Ashima Garg, MD, PhD; James Chang, MD; Claire Spanbock, MBA, RN, CNOR; Edgar Servais; Bijal Shah, MHSA; Tamar Fendel, MPH; Annie Davis, MPH; Joeffrey Hatton, MBA

Mid-Atlantic States Chronic Heart Failure Program
Farzaneh Sabi, MD; Machelle Behzadi, MHA; Betty Rice; Jessica Kane; Blair Van-Horn

Patient-Centered Management for Chronic Disease—A Model Applied to Parkinson Disease Care in Southern California
Jason Cheves, MSBA; Steve Cedrone, MBA; Todd Sachs, MD; Kathy Kigerl, RN, MN

Coordinated Regionwide Care Management Intervention for Patient with Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease at Risk of Acute Exacerbation Reduces Hospital Days
Richard Mularski, MD, MSHS, MCR; Sanja Uskokovic, MS, PMP; David M Mosen, PhD; Bryan L Skalberg, MS; Achikam Haim, PhD; Marianne C Turley, PhD; Nancy L Lee, RPh; Wui-Leong Koh, MD

Decreasing Sleepless Nights for Patients and Practitioners by Fast Tracking Patients with Diagnostic Images Highly Suspicious for Cancer
Rischl Alindogan, BSN; Brian Doerning, MD; Robert Lin, MD; Jamie Difiori, MD; Harold Chow, MD; James Carter, RPA; Cynthia Payne, PhD

Combining Minimally Invasive Thoracic Surgery Techniques and a Multidisciplinary Care Model Leads to Superior Outcomes
Brian Timm, PA-C; Christopher Mutrie, MD; Piotr Starosta, PA-C; Julie Faulk, PA-C; German Collazo, PA-C; Yong Shin, MD; William Shely, MD; Thomas Lampros, MD; David Tse, MD

Patient-Centered Redesign of Total Joint Replacement Care: Achieving the Quadruple Aim
Kate Koplan MD, MPH, FACP, CPPS; Violeta Rabrenovich, MHA, CHIE

HIV/AIDS: A 30-Year History of Care Delivery
Patricia L Philbin, RN; Karen Lewis Smith, MHA; Susan McDonald, RN, MSN; Kathy Brown MD, FACP, AAHIVS; Dan Kent, PharmD

Enhancing Dispositions from the Emergency Department—the Northern California Journey to Care for Increasingly Complex Populations
Rayne Soriano PhD, RN; Vivian Reyes, MD; Jo-Ann Griffin, RN

Mid-Atlantic States Hospital Patient Day Rate Reduction
Farzaneh Sabi, MD; Pam Galley, MAOL; Claire Pagano, MHA; Blair Van-Horn

Preventing “Silent Droppers”: Standardizing Interventions to Prevent Lung Function Decline in Patients with Cystic Fibrosis
Jennifer Bass, MD; Adrienne Aldredge, MS; Ashley Addington; Richard Cohen, MD; Megan Danish; Susan Mikkelsen, MD; Kay Pasquesi; Kimberly Rondeau; Megan Wackford; Eric Walter, MD

EQUITY

Igniting an Inclusive Movement—Utilizing ILEaD (Inclusively Leading Through Equity and Diversity)
Laura Long, MBA; Susan Terrill

Addressing Disparities in Health with Motivational Interviewing
Deborah Baker, PhD; Hyewon Jun, MD, MPH; Dee Keyser; Peggy Latare, MD

The Community Action Poverty Simulation
Lakiesha C Tidwell; Madalynne Wilkes-Grundy, MD; Shari G Chevez, MD; Anna Khachikyan

MEDICATION MANAGEMENT

Reducing Opiate Use in Children and Teens: A Strategic Approach to a National Challenge
Anna Grosz, MD

Impact of Medication Reconciliation Programs on Reducing Readmission Rate and Enhancing Medication Safety During Transitions of Care
Alfonso Becerra, PharmD; Donald Yee, RPh; Karen Cham, PharmD; Sheireen Huang, PharmD; Shubhi Nagrani, PharmD; Adenola Akilo, PharmD; Karina Briones, PharmD; Kelvin Chan, PharmD; Carolyn Woo, PharmD; Chad Friday, RPh

PATIENT ENGAGEMENT

Human-Centered Design at Kaiser Permanente: A Creative Approach to Problem Solving
Jeff Hall; Connor Shea; Estee Neuwirth, PhD

Meeting Members’ Wishes in the Last Year of Life: A Journey Toward Concordance in Southern California
David Glass; PhD Michael Kanter, MD; Paul Minardi, MD; Susan Wang, MD

Using Insights from End-of-Life Care Survey to Drive Improvement of Care at the End of Life
Margaret C Wang, PhD, MPH; Diane Brown, PhD, RN, FNAHQ, FAAN; Peter S Khang, MD; Ruma Kumar, MD

Reducing Preventive Flips to Diagnostic—A Holistic Approach to Improving the Financial Experience for Members
Peter Gazanian; Erin Bilvado, MBA

TOTAL HEALTH

How Healthy Is My Community—Designing a Measurement System for Leaders and Implementers
Pamela M Schwartz, MPH; Elisa Wong, MPH; Allen D Cheadle, PhD; John M Vu, MPH

If You Want to Know How Mrs Smith is Doing, Ask Her! KP’s Improved Medicare Total Health/Social Risk Assessment
Tracy Lippard, MD, FACP; Carole Gardner, MD, AGSF; Matt Stiefel, MPA, MS; Ranu Pandey, MHA; Juliana Oronos, MPH

Bridging Barriers to Care Access and Delivery: The Automation of Nonemergent Transportation in Kaiser Permanente Mid-Atlantic States
Kyle M Heidenberger; Rachel E Hill; Melissa Baldwin, MS, MBA; Jason C McCarthy, PharmD, MBA

Addressing Social Needs: Organizational Learnings and Connecting with Our Communities
Sarita A Mohanty, MD, MPH, MBA; John F Steiner, MD, MPH; Nicole Friedman, MS; Briar Ertz-Berger, MD, MPH

TEAMS

The Kaiser Permanente Northwest Ventricular Assist Device Program
Barbara Amos, RN, MSN, CNS; Timothy Jacobson, MD; Yong Shin, MD; Ryan Morrissey, MD; Siobhan Gray, MD; Pamela Montes, RN, MSN; Allison Lipnick, LCSW

In-Basket Management: Empowering Nurses to be First Responders for Patient Messages, Providing The Right Care at The Right Time
Dones M Trojillo, MSN, RN; Maia M Patel, MD, ScM

The Implementation of High-Reliability Organization Model for the Environmental Services Department at Santa Clara Medical Center
Eric Williams, MHSA; Kari Frank, MS; Marc Smith, MHA

Building A Virtual Nursing Team: Implementation of the Advance Alert Monitor
Laure E Lisk, RN, MS, CPHQ, CPHRM; Elizabeth Scruth, RN, PhD, MPH, CCNS, CCRN, FCCM; Vanessa Martinez, MSN, MPH, RN; Bronwyn Cox, MSN, RN; Kris Wilson, RN, MSN, CPHQ

Improving Quality and Safety Together: Reducing Primary Cesareans Perinatal Core Measure Collaborative
Lyn Yasumura, MD; Cheri Lowre, MD; Leslie Casper, MD; Marianna Volodarskiy, RN, MSN, NE-BC

TECHNOLOGY

Leveraging Technology to Improve Appropriate Imaging Studies: There’s an App for That!
Peter Huynh, MD; Paymann Moin, MD; Michael Flores; Pamela Galvan; Steven Ethington

Using Human-Centered Design to Expand Telehealth Into the Hospital and Continuum
Reema Shah MPH; Estee Neuwirth, PhD; Lan Nguyen; Carissa Lim; George Go, MD; Tamara Hillstrom; Dan Huynh, MD; Margaret Pierce; Colette Lundahl; David Miura; Lisa Arellanes

Home Health Virtual Complexivist Physician Program: Leveraging Increased Scope of Care at a Crucial Time
Alicia Ahn, MD; Sandra Barton, MD; Binitha X Surendran, MBA, MS

Improving Patient Safety Via Information Transparency and Performance-Improvement Infrastructure
Asia Plahar, MS, RN; Kathy Ricossa, MS, RN

Read more...

CIRCULATION

27,000 print readers per quarter, 15,350 eTOC readers, and in 2018, 2 million page views of TPJ articles in PubMed from a broad international readership.

Indexing

Indexed in MEDLINE, PubMed Central, HINARI, EMBASE, EBSCO Academic Search Complete, rdrb, CrossRef, and SciVerse/Scopus.

e-TOC

Click here to join the eTOC list or text TPJ to 22828. You will receive an Email notice with the Table of Contents of each issue.


                                             

 

 

ISSN 1552-5767 Copyright © 2019 thepermanentejournal.org.

All Rights Reserved.