Doctors as Patients

Doctors as Patients

When Doctors Become Patients by Robert Klitzman; When Doctors Get Sick by Harvey Mandell, Howard Spiro; When Doctors
are Patients by Max Pinner, MD, Benjamin Miller, MD


Review by Vincent J Felitti, MD, FACP

Fall 2009 - Volume 13 Number 4

Doctors as PatientsIt is commonly said (especially by nurses and wives) that doctors make terrible patients. When Doctors Become Patients is a serious and insightful exploration of the point. Certainly, many physician-patients have written critically about the way they were treated as patients, mainly focusing on their treatment as human beings. This book takes on the more difficult task of analyzing our emotional responses to being sick, not our responses to disease or treatment. The author has done a superb job of interviewing a number of physicians who are seriously ill, deconstructing the interviews, and reassembling their responses around several core themes like life and death, certainty and uncertainty, loss and self-esteem, and anxiety and denial.

When Doctors Become Patients is thus structured quite differently from two earlier, equally important, and interesting approaches to the subject: When Doctors Get Sick, by Harvey Mandell and Howard Spiro, and When Doctors are Patients, by Max Pinner, MD, and Benjamin Miller, MD. These latter two books are valuable compendia of case report descriptions by seveDoctors as Patients

Robert Klitzman, MD, makes the observation that personal illness is singularly difficult for physicians because we frequently define ourselves by our work and hence are resistant to relegating medical responsibility to others for our own evaluation or treatment. He points out how we are taught to treat disease, not about being sick. I am thus reminded how pleased I was some years ago, in the early stages of a cerebellar stroke, with my diagnostic acumen at recognizing the diagnosis. The thought never even crossed my mind to ask for help, which was done only at my wife's insistence: I was a doctor, not a patient. Using more blunt terminology, denial of illness is a major point of focus in the book's opening chapters, even if we avoid the very idea in medical practice by renaming it patient noncompliance. Feelings, after all, are not very often explored. Who of us ever asked a patient how they felt about having a myocardial infarction, lung cancer, or dying?

Dr Klitzman has a chapter on our coming out as patients, an interesting point reminding one of how obituaries refer to people passing away after prolonged illnesses instead of dying of some specified cancer. As one interviewed physician says, "I felt as if we were living double lives, as if we were prisoners twice"—because of both illness and secrecy. Part 2 deals with being a doctor after being a patient. A meaningful number of physicians sought alternative treatments in addition to conventional allopathic medicine. Workaholism and retirement are practical sections. Part 3 deals with subsequently changed patient interactions by those continuing to work. The chapter on improving medical education is excellent, a sorely needed topic of improvement.Doctors as Patients

All told, this is a significant book that will be meaningful to many physicians. Those of us administratively involved will do well to remember it when discussions again come up about improving physician morale. There is a lot to be said for understanding what is really going on, whether in patients or ourselves, including in ourselves as patients.


The Permanente Journal

Sponsored by the eight Permanente Medical Groups, The Permanente Journal advances knowledge in scientific research, clinical medicine, and innovative health care delivery.

Reprint Permissions

The Permanente Journal welcomes requests for reprints and reproduction. Use of any and all material published in The Permanente Journal is copyrighted and protected.

The Permanente Press

The Permanente Press publishes The Permanente Journal and books related to healthcare. Journal subscriptions are entered for the calendar year. Advance payment in US dollars is required.

ISSN 1552-5775 Copyright © 2018

The Permanente Press. All Rights Reserved.